Prescott Ford
Principal

For decades, regulatory risk has been treated as a cost of doing business, something to be managed defensively, documented thoroughly and resolved as quickly as possible. The prevailing posture has been reactive: Find the finding, fix the finding, move on.

The Office of the Comptroller of the Currency and Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. have again changed the rules — not just procedurally this time, but philosophically. The banks that recognize and capitalize on this shift the earliest will carry a meaningful advantage into the next cycles. There is now potential to turn compliance costs into profit.

On November 2, the OCC and the FDIC final rule became effective that establishes the first codified regulatory definition of “unsafe or unsound practice” in federal banking law. More important operationally is what it does to Matters Requiring Attention (MRAs) already on the books.

A practice is unsafe or unsound now only when connected to financial harm. The MRA standard requires that harm could reasonably be expected under foreseeable conditions. A new supervisory observation category sits below that, with no mandatory remediation or board action.

The final rule establishes three tiers, each with a different burden. The question for every bank is not just where its findings sit today, but whether it has the risk management infrastructure to operate across all three.

Community banks face a higher materiality threshold assessed at the whole-institution level; an isolated weakness in one product line is less likely to produce an MRA. Larger, more complex banks face lower materiality thresholds as risk rises, and MRAs can now target a single business line.

Meanwhile, the OCC has also revised its MRA closure standard: once corrective actions are implemented and validated, the finding must be closed. Examiners can no longer hold an MRA open to observe sustained performance over time. For banks with longstanding open findings, this is a meaningful shift in leverage.

The FDIC conducted a formal lookback of all outstanding board-level matters and supervisory recommendations. Banks will receive written notice of which items become MRAs and which are closed. That notice deserves scrutiny. Banks should verify the result against their own inventory and confirm that every finding eligible for closure was in fact, closed. OCC-supervised banks had examiners at the local level conduct a less formal lookback , making their own internal review more urgent.

The Opportunity Right Now
The new rule presents a strategic opening.

1. Close MRAs that no longer meet the bar. Bank management should closely evaluate open MRAs to identify those that would not meet the new materiality standard and make closure arguments while the transition is fresh.

2. Verify the lookback. Examiners reviewed all outstanding findings before the effective date. Confirm that every MRA eligible for closure was, in fact, closed.

3. Convert compliance cost into fuel to drive return on equity. Resources freed from immaterial findings can be redirected toward productive activity. Strategically approaching regulatory risk management will empower growth and optimization.

4. Build governance that works for you. Observations still inform CAMELS ratings. Banks with sound risk management frameworks will navigate that tier with confidence. Those without one will put themselves at risk to turns in the cycles.

Where the Bar Is Higher
What this rule does not do is reduce the obligation to manage risk. Supervisory observations carry no formal requirements, but they inform CAMELS ratings and reflect on management. A bank that declines to act on an observation should document the reasoned basis against its board-approved risk appetite. The absence of a formal finding is not the same as the absence of risk. Examiners do identify real risks that are not being adequately measured, monitored or controlled. A risk that may not trigger an MRA may still warrant strong attention because that protects the business.

Compliance is a discipline, not a defense mechanism. It defines how a bank operates within its risk appetite, not whether it can. The banks that internalize this framing will use this rule as an invitation to close what qualifies, honestly assess what remains and build governance that treats risk management as a source of operational strength rather than a regulatory burden.

Good risk management is good business. This rule raises the bar for what that requires, and it rewards the banks prepared to meet it.

WRITTEN BY

Prescott Ford

Principal

Prescott Ford, CFA is a Principal at SolomonEdwards and a retired OCC Supervisory National Bank Examiner with more than 20 years of federal banking supervision experience. He writes on regulatory risk management strategy.